IRS Program Criticized by GOP Lawmakers: The Future of Tax Filing Hangs in the Balance

Man speaking at podium with American flags behind.

Trump’s IRS pick sparks controversy: A former auctioneer with no college degree nominated to lead a $12 billion agency.

At a Glance

  • President-elect Trump nominates Billy Long as IRS Commissioner, raising eyebrows
  • Republicans push to end IRS Direct File program, calling it “unauthorized and wasteful”
  • Long’s unconventional background includes promoting controversial tax credit linked to fraud
  • IRS faces potential $20 billion funding cut and shift in enforcement priorities
  • Debate intensifies over government’s role in tax preparation and collection

Trump’s Controversial IRS Pick Ignites Debate

President-elect Donald Trump has nominated former Missouri Congressman Billy Long as IRS Commissioner, igniting a firestorm of debate about the future of tax policy and IRS operations. Long, a certified auctioneer with limited tax experience and no college degree, is set to oversee an agency with 85,000 employees and a $12 billion annual budget. This unconventional choice has drawn criticism from Democrats and raised questions about the potential politicization of the IRS.

Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) voiced his concerns about the nomination, suggesting it could lead to Trump controlling the IRS. The current IRS Commissioner, Danny Werfel, appointed by President Biden, has a term that doesn’t expire until 2027. This overlap has intensified the political battle over the agency’s leadership and direction.

“If Trump fires Mr. Werfel, it won’t be to improve on his work; it’ll be to install somebody Trump can control as he meddles with the IRS.” – Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.)

Despite the criticism, Trump stands by his choice, stating, “Taxpayers and the exceptional staff at the IRS will appreciate having Billy in charge.” This endorsement comes as the IRS faces significant challenges, including a proposed $20 billion reduction in special funding and a $2.2 billion budget cut.

Republican Push to End IRS Direct File Program

As the debate over IRS leadership unfolds, Republican lawmakers are urging President-elect Trump to terminate the IRS Direct File program. This initiative, which allows taxpayers to submit simple tax returns directly to the IRS for free, has been labeled “unauthorized and wasteful” by its critics. In 2024, 140,000 Americans utilized this service, which was initially piloted in 12 states and expanded to 12 additional states for the 2025 tax filing season.

Republicans argue that the IRS acting as both tax preparer and enforcer creates a conflict of interest. A letter signed by multiple Republican representatives calls for the immediate termination of the Direct File program, asserting that it’s inappropriate for the IRS to serve as a tax preparer. This stance aligns with the conservative governance blueprint outlined in Project 2025, which calls for a simplified tax system.

Potential Shifts in IRS Focus and Tax Policy

Long’s appointment could signal a significant shift in the IRS’s priorities, potentially moving away from enforcing tax compliance among high-income individuals and corporations. This aligns with Republican plans to reshape tax policy before key aspects of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) expire. Priorities include making individual tax cuts permanent and maintaining a lower corporate tax rate.

“We’re excited about the improvements to Direct File and the millions more taxpayers who will be eligible to use the service this year.” – IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel

The controversy surrounding Long’s nomination is further fueled by his promotion of the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC), which has been associated with widespread fraud. An IRS review found that 70%-90% of ERTC claims show signs of fraud or error, representing over $86 billion in potentially improper claims. This raises concerns about Long’s judgment and his ability to effectively lead the agency in combating tax fraud.

The Future of Tax Filing Hangs in the Balance

As the confirmation process for Long’s nomination unfolds, the debate over the future of tax filing in America intensifies. The IRS Direct File program, championed by the current administration as a way to simplify tax filing and broaden deduction eligibility, faces an uncertain future under potential new leadership. This ongoing controversy highlights the stark differences in philosophy between Republicans and Democrats on how the government should handle federal tax administration and balance taxpayer service provision.

The outcome of this debate will have far-reaching implications for millions of American taxpayers. As we await the results of the confirmation process and potential policy changes, one thing is clear: the landscape of tax filing in the United States is poised for significant transformation, with the interests of hardworking citizens hanging in the balance.

​

Sources:

  1. IRS Shakeup? What Trump’s Commissioner Pick Could Mean for Taxes
  2. IRS Tax Filing Change Proposed Under Donald Trump

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR